After finding out last week that Nestle purchased 3 previously reputable supplement companies (Seroyal, Pure Encapsulations, and Douglas Labs), I thought it would be great to publish this older article from a colleague discussing the factors she (and I) consider when recommending a particular company or supplement.
Remember that supplements are not regulated by the FDA, which means the claims on the bottle have not been verified by any authorities or regulators. Also, most manufacturing companies don’t produce the raw material they include in their product. So, if they aren’t testing to make sure that’s ginkgo biloba they received, it very well could just be ground up oak leaves or common grass.
When supplements are cheap, sadly there is often a reason.
The Winding, Global Path of Dietary Supplements: Sniffing Out the Trail of Quality to its Source
3/1/2011 Natural Medicine Journal
by: Lise Alschuler, ND, FABNO
One of the pleasures of winter in New England is its revelation of the wonder of my dog’s nose. During our walks at any other time of year, with her nose pressed to the ground, it appears as if my dog is enthusiastically, albeit randomly, on the hunt for something—anything—that she hasn’t found yet. However, in the winter, those apparently random sniffs are transformed before my eyes into a precise tracing of an animal’s trail. With the help of tracks left in the snow, I can now see the trail that my dog’s nose is leading her along. It amazes me how accurate she is in staying on the trail, and I know that, with enough time, she could easily follow the trail all the way to its source.
Dietary supplement products leave their own trails; however, I think my dog would meet her match in trying to follow these paths. For one thing, the trails leading to dietary supplements start in all parts of the globe. For another, the trails branch and intersect their way to the final product. There are very few linear, entirely transparent paths from starting material to finished product. As ingredients work their way from their original source to the final product, they can be mixed with the same ingredient from other parts of the world. The ingredients, while the same by name, may have different histories of cultivation, processing, extraction, and testing. The globalization of the dietary supplement industry along with the increasing demand on ingredients has turned the traceability into a veritable maze.
The globalization of the dietary supplement industry along with the increasing demand on ingredients has turned the traceability into a veritable maze.
In the midst of this layered and complex supply chain, manufacturers are left with the formidable challenge of identifying safe and pure ingredients that they can reliably utilize in their products. Thus, manufacturers source every ingredient with a myriad of considerations in mind. These considerations include things like ingredient price, availability, quality, processing, and traceability. A good manufacturer will set specifications for each of these areas and will use these specifications to determine from whom to purchase their ingredients. While this may seem challenging enough, to make matters even more complicated, for many ingredients there are multiple layers of supply. An ingredient may actually be sourced from multiple suppliers around the globe, and then mixed and sold to the manufacturer by a broker of that ingredient. This layering of suppliers can make it very challenging to identify the traceability of raw materials. Ultimately, manufacturers have three choices. They can decide to test every receipt of raw material for all known quality attributes (ie, identity, potency, known possible contaminants); they can vertically integrate, taking responsibility for all of their products’ ingredients from seed to bottle; or they can qualify their raw material suppliers to be reliable purveyors of acceptable-quality materials and do skip-lot testing verification. The majority of dietary supplement manufacturers fall into this last category.
The process of evaluating the source of ingredients is referred to as supplier qualification. Supplier qualification is a complex and involved process that really goes beyond the scope of this article. However, a few of its key components are worth mentioning, as this is such a critical part of the supply chain and traceability. Supplier qualification is typically risk-based. Through a variety of analyses, manufacturers can determine which of their suppliers represent the highest and the lowest risks. A supplier of raw materials that is a pharmaceutical company making commodity ingredients such as ascorbic acid or glycerin, for instance, may be determined to be low risk. On the other hand, a small or new supplier of botanical or complex nutraceutical ingredients like curcumin standardized extract or chondroitin sulfate may be considered high risk. High-risk suppliers require extensive qualification that involves an analysis of the company’s quality practices, on-site audits, repeated validation of the company’s certificate of analysis through independent testing, and a thorough understanding of the traceability of the ingredients provided by the supplier. Given the increasing globalization of the supply chain, the importance of frequent and thorough checkpoints as an integral part of supplier qualification cannot be overstated.
It is the responsibility of dietary supplement manufacturers to ensure that their products contain the intended ingredients and are absent of contaminants. This is achieved through a combination of extensive testing, thorough supplier qualification, and ingredient traceability. As practitioners and consumers of dietary supplements, traceability should be very important to us. While this trail can be very difficult to sniff out, it is not impossible. Fortunately, there are some excellent, well-maintained trails to follow—trails that reputable manufacturers would be happy to guide you along.
Dr. Lise Alschuler, ND, FABNO, is the vice president of quality and education at Emerson Ecologics, a distributor of professional brands of supplements to healthcare practitioners and home of the Emerson Quality Program (EQP), a quality verification program of dietary supplement manufacturers. Alschuler is also a practicing naturopathic physician, published author, and co-creator of Cancer Thrivers.